Our Menu
Served Monday - Friday 11-Close, Saturday and Sunday 3-Close. Substitute any gluten item with gluten-free: bread, buns, pizza crust and pasta
Appetizers
MEATBALLS
$14.00
handmade meatballs tossed in one of our signature sauces: bbq with pickle slaw - buffalo with shaved celery - scratch made tomato sauce with garlic bread - zesty asian with asian slaw
FANCY TOTS
$12.00
fresh potatoes, montamore and fontina cheeses, green onions, fancy sauce
LOADED BRUSSELS
$13.50
crispy brussel sprouts, whipped feta, house made giardiniera, lemon zest
CHEESE CURDS
$12.00
wisconsin cheese curds with scratch made tomato sauce
WINGS
$16.00
traditional or boneless | buffalo, backyard bbq, zesty asian, nashville hot, lemon ranch, garlic parmesan
BRUSCHETTA
$12.00
house made garlic crostini topped with herb cream cheese, roma tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, balsamic glaze
CHARCUTERIE PRETZEL
$17.00
jumbo soft pretzel with beer cheese, honey mustard, and chef’s selection of accompaniments (ask your server for daily creation)
CRAN + FETA WHIPPED HUMMUS
$12.00
house made hummus mixed with whipped feta topped with a sweet cranberry reduction served with garlic crostinis
SWEET HEAT SHRIMP
$14.00
grilled shrimp coated in Chef Zach's signature sauce presented on a bed of spring mix tossed with lemon and olive oil
Handhelds
includes french fries; additional sides available upon request
ITALIAN TURKEY CLUB
$16.00
herbed focaccia with turkey, lettuce, bacon, fresh mozzarella, scratch made tomato sauce, balsamic reduction
CRISPY CHICKEN
$18.00
panko crusted marinated chicken breast with pickles, lettuce, Cry Baby Craig's aioli on brioche
MEATBALL SUB
$16.00
handmade meatballs, scratch made tomato sauce, melted mozzarella on a hoagie
CHICKEN PARMESAN
$18.00
parmesan crusted chicken breast topped with a cheese blend and our scratch made tomato sauce served on herbed focaccia bread
ITALIAN BEEF
$17.00
shaved ny strip, american cheese, giardiniera on a hoagie served with au jus
SHORT RIB TACOS
$14.00
Braised beef, corn salsa, lettuce, cheddar, avocado cream on corn tortillas
Soups
CREAMY TOMATO BASIL CROCK
$9.00
garlic, tomatoes, basil with a splash of cream
FRENCH ONION CROCK
$9.00
classic made from scratch signature recipe
Salads
enjoy topped with a protein*
BEET SALAD
$9.00/half
$15.00/full
spring mix, roasted beets, goat cheese, pistachios, orange vinaigrette
HOUSE SALAD
$7.00/half
$13.00/full
spring mix, carrots, tomatoes, shredded cheese
SOUTHWEST SALAD
$9.00/half
$16.00/full
spring mix, avocado, queso, fresco, corn, tomato, cilantro, chili-spiced tortilla chips, chipotle ranch
CAESAR SALAD
$9.00/half
$15.00/full
romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, garlic croutons, caesar dressing
Pastas
enjoy topped with a protein*
PAPPARDELLI PARMESAN
$17.00
Pappardelli noodles, heavy cream, sea salt, black pepper, parmigiano reggiano
MAC & CHEESE
$17.00
cavatappi noodles, creamy cheddar cheese sauce
BUCATINI & MEATBALLS
$18.00
bucatini pasta with scratch made tomato sauce, meatballs, sprinkled with parmesan
BEEF STROGANOFF
$22.00
tender beef tip sautéed with wild mushrooms, garlic and red wine served over wide noodles and drizzled with crème fraîche
CHICKEN PARMESAN
$22.00
bucatini pasta, crispy chicken breast, mozzarella cheese with scratch made tomato sauce
*Proteins
SALMON FILLET
$11.00
SHRIMP
$11.00
NY STRIP (5 oz)
$12.00
SHORT RIB
$7.00
GRILLED CHICKEN
$7.00
CRISPY CHICKEN
$7.00
Pizza
handmade dough, scratch made pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, brick oven finish; all pizzas are ~12 in
HOUSE SPECIAL
$16.00
sausage, pepperoni, onion, peppers, mushrooms, olives, feta
ITALIAN
$16.00
tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella, tuscan olive oil, balsamic
THE BASICS
$16.00
pepperoni or sausage
JUST CHEESE
$13.00
TOPPINGS
$3.00/each
additional toppings available: pepperoni, sausage, grilled chicken, meatballs, onion, bell pepper, banana pepper, mushrooms, green olives, artichokes, spinach, canadian bacon, pineapple, fresh mozzarella, feta, goat cheese
Burgers
served on a hearty bun includes french fries; additional sides available upon request
THE COWBOY
$17.00
backyard bbq, cheddar, hickory bacon, thick onion ring
FREE SPIRIT
$17.00
rattlesnake cheese, jalapeños, chili cheese Fritos, guac, Cry Baby Craig's aiol
SWEET ON SAVORY (S.O.S.)
$17.00
pepper candied bacon, walnut aioli, lettuce, herbed cheese spread
VAT 17
$18.00
award-winning Deer Creek Vat 17 white cheddar, arugula, candied bacon, roasted garlic aioli
PAULIE’S PLAIN BURGER
$14.00
plain burger or build your own
Sides
FRENCH FRIES
$4.00
WAVY SWEET FRIES
$5.00
FANCY TOTS
$6.00
CHEESE CURDS
$6.00
MAC & CHEESE
$7.00
BRUSSELS SPROUTS
$5.00
LOADED SPROUTS
$7.00
SMALL HOUSE SALAD
$7.00
CHEF’S VEGETABLE
$5.00
PLATES
FISH FRY
$25.00
walleye fillet dipped in seasoned flour and flash fried, served with french fries and house made coleslaw
MAPLE GLAZED SALMON
$27.00
fresh cut grilled salmon, garlic maple glaze, roasted fingerling potatoes, chef’s choice vegetables
ITALIAN SURF & TURF
$36.00
10 oz ny strip, roasted button mushrooms, house made steak sauce, lobster ravioli, white wine butter cream sauce
Available Monday - Friday from 11 am - 3 pm
Half Pizza + Salad
HALF PIZZA + SIDE SALAD
$10.00
one topping pizza with handmade dough, scratch made pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, brick oven finish + spring mix, carrots, tomatoes, shredded cheese
UPGRADE TO HALF SIGNATURE SALAD
$14.00
choose from one of Paulie's signature salads: beet salad, southwest salad, or caesar salad
UPGRADE TO FULL SIGNATURE SALAD
$20.00
choose from one of Paulie's signature salads: beet salad, southwest salad, or caesar salad
TOPPINGS
$1.00/each
additional toppings available: pepperoni, sausage, grilled chicken, meatballs, onion, bell pepper, banana pepper, mushrooms, green olives, artichokes, spinach, canadian bacon, pineapple, fresh mozzarella, feta, goat cheese
HALF PASTA + SALAD
MAC & CHEESE + SIDE SALAD
$10.00
cavatappi noodles, rich and creamy cheddar cheese sauce + spring mix, carrots, tomatoes, shredded cheese
PAPPARDELLE PARMESAN + SIDE SALAD
$10.00
pappardelle noodles, heavy cream, sea salt, black pepper, parmigiano reggiano + spring mix, carrots, tomatoes, shredded cheese
BUCATINI & MEATBALLS + SIDE SALAD
$10.00
bucatini pasta with scratch made tomato sauce, meatballs, sprinkled with parmesan + spring mix, carrots, tomatoes, shredded cheese
UPGRADE TO HALF SIGNATURE SALAD
$14.00
choose from one of Paulie's signature salads: beet salad, southwest salad, or caesar salad
UPGRADE TO FULL SIGNATURE SALAD
$20.00
choose from one of Paulie's signature salads: beet salad, southwest salad, or caesar salad
Available Saturday 11 am - 3 pm & Sunday 10 am - 3 pm; Substitute any gluten item with gluten-free: bread, buns, pizza crust and pasta
BRUNCH
MAMAS BREAKFAST
$14.00
gouda hashbrowns, 2 eggs your way, choice of meat, toast
PAULIE’S EGG “SKILLET”
$16.00
2 eggs your way served over potatoes fried with onions, bell peppers and Paulie’s breakfast sausage topped with shredded cheese and hollandaise sauce
VEGGIE EGG “SKILLET”
$15.00
2 eggs your way served over potatoes fried with onions, bell peppers and spinach topped with shredded cheese and hollandaise sauce
BREAKFAST PIZZA
$16.00
Paulie’s pizza crust topped with hollandaise sauce, scrambled eggs, bacon, italian sausage and shredded cheese
FRENCH TOAST
$12.00
cinnamon vanilla toast topped with powdered sugar, fruit, whipped cream, syrup and smoked maple butter
BISCUITS & GRAVY
$15.00
biscuit, sausage gravy, gouda hashbrowns, 2 eggs your way
SMOKED SALMON BENEDICT
$18.00
english muffin, smoked salmon, 2 poached eggs, gouda hashbrowns, hollandaise sauce
AVOCADO TOAST
$14.00
avocado, zesty lime juice, red pepper, onion, sautéed mushrooms, eggs your way, served on toasted sourdough with a side of fresh fruit
APPETIZERS
MEATBALLS
$14.00
handmade meatballs tossed in one of our signature sauces: bbq with pickle slaw - buffalo with shaved celery - scratch made tomato sauce with garlic bread - zesty asian with asian slaw
FANCY TOTS
$12.00
fresh potatoes, montamore and fontina cheeses, green onions, fancy sauce
LOADED SRPOUTS
$13.50
crispy brussel sprouts, whipped feta, house made giardiniera, lemon zest
CHEESE CURDS
$12.00
wisconsin cheese cubes, scratch made tomato sauce
WINGS
$16.00
traditional or boneless. buffalo, backyard bbq, zesty asian, nashville hot, lemon ranch, garlic parmesan
BRUSCHETTA
$12.00
house made garlic crostini topped herb cream cheese, roma tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, balsamic glaze
CHARCUTERIE PRETZEL
$17.00
jumbo soft pretzel with beer cheese, honey mustard, and chef’s selection of accompaniments (ask your server for daily creation)
CRAN + FETA WHIPPED HUMMUS
$12.00
house made hummus mixed with whipped feta topped with a sweet cranberry reduction served with garlic crostinis
SWEET HEAT SHRIMP
$14.00
grilled shrimp coated in Chef Zach's signature sauce presented on a bed of spring mix tossed with lemon and olive oil
SALADS
enjoy topped with a protein*
BEET SALAD
$9.00/half
$15.00/full
spring mix with roasted beets, goat cheese, pistachios, orange vinaigrette
HOUSE SALAD
$7.00/half
$13.00/full
spring mix, carrots, tomatoes, shredded cheese
CAESAR SALAD
$9.00/half
$15.00/full
romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, garlic croutons, caesar dressing
SOUTHWEST SALAD
$9.00/half
$16.00/full
spring mix, avocado, queso, fresco, corn, tomato, cilantro, chili-spiced tortilla chips, chipotle ranch
SOUPS
CREAMY TOMATO BASIL CROCK
$9.00
garlic, tomatoes, basil with a splash of cream
FRENCH ONION CROCK
$9.00
classic made from scratch signature recipe
BURGERS
served on a hearty bun includes french fries; additional sides available upon request
THE COWBOY
$17.00
backyard bbq, cheddar, hickory bacon, thick onion ring
FREE SPIRIT
$17.00
rattlesnake cheese, jalapeños, chili cheese Fritos, guac, Cry Baby Craig's aioli | 17
SWEET ON SAVORY (S.O.S.)
$17.00
pepper candied bacon, walnut aioli, lettuce, herbed cream cheese spread
PAULIE’S PLAIN BURGER
$14.00
plain burger or build your own
PIZZA
handmade dough, scratch made pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, brick oven finish; all pizzas are ~12 in
HOUSE SPECIAL
$16.00
sausage, pepperoni, onion, peppers, mushrooms, olives, feta
ITALIAN
$16.00
tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella, tuscan olive oil, balsamic
THE BASICS
$16.00
pepperoni or sausage
JUST CHEESE
$13.00
TOPPINGS
$3.00/each
toppings available: pepperoni, sausage, grilled chicken, meatballs, onion, bell pepper, banana pepper, mushrooms, green olives, artichokes, spinach, canadian bacon, pineapple, fresh mozzarella, feta, goat cheese
PASTA
enjoy topped with a protein*
MAC & CHEESE
$17.00
cavatappi noodles, rich and creamy cheddar cheese sauce
PAPPARDELLE PARMESAN
$17.00
pappardelle noodles, heavy cream, sea salt, black pepper and parmigiana reggiano
SIDES
FRENCH FRIES
$4.00
WAVY SWEET FRIES
$5.00
FANCY TOTS
$6.00
CHEESE CURDS
$6.00
MAC & CHEESE
$7.00
BRUSSEL SPROUTS
$5.00
LOADED SPROUTS
$7.00
SMALL HOUSE SALAD
$7.00
CHEF’S VEGETABLE
$5.00
*PROTEINS
SHRIMP
$11.00
SALMON FILLET
$11.00
NY STRIP (5 oz)
$12.00
SHORT RIB
$7.00
GRILLED CHICKEN
$7.00
CRISPY CHICKEN
$7.00
Available Monday - Saturday from 3 - 6 pm
Drink
BEER
$5.00
Fulton Lonely Blonde | Urban Growler Cowbell Cream Ale | Bell's Two Hearted | Michelob Golden Light | Foggy Geezer
WINE
$6.00
Torresella Pinot Grigio | Arani Sauvignon Blanc | Bogle Rose | Sand Point Pinot Noir | Colosi Red Blend | Crios Malbec
Food
APPETIZERS
$7.00
Cheese Curds | Loaded Sprouts | Fancy Tots | Half Pepperoni Pizza | Poutine | Bruschetta | Garlic Parmesan Fries
Dessert
Save some room?
PAULIE'S ANNIVERSARY CAKE
$12.00
four layers of moist chocolate cake, double chocolate mousse filling, ganache icing
FLOURLESS CHOCOLATE TORTE
$9.00
dense and rich chocolate cake (gluten free)
TIRAMASU
$12.00
mascarpone cream, kahlua and espresso-soaked ladyfingers, cocoa powder
PEANUT BUTTER CUP
$9.00
dark chocolate, whipped peanut butter (gluten free)
Menu
Guests ages 12 & under include applesauce, kids milk or soda
GRILLED CHICKEN
$10.00
grilled chicken breast, fries
STEAK BITES
$10.00
grilled steak, fries
MINI MAC
$7.00
kids portion of our house made mac + cheese, garlic bread
CHICKEN BITES
$7.00
chicken bites, fries
HANGRY BURGER
$7.00
burger, fries | add cheese +.50
NOODLES
$7.00
buttered noodles, garlic bread
CHEESE PLEASE
$7.00
grilled cheese on sourdough, fries
HASH IT OUT
$7.00
eggs, hashbrowns | available during brunch only